If you’re tackling a big cleanup project, home renovation, or commercial job in Winnipeg, choosing the right size bin can make or break your junk removal experience. One of the most common questions we hear from Mr. Garbage is:
“Should I go for a big bin rental or a small bin rental?”
The answer? It depends on your project type, the volume of waste, your location, and how long you’ll need the bin. In this post, we’ll compare big bin rental vs small bin rental in Winnipeg so you can make an informed decision—without overpaying or running out of space.
Understanding Bin Sizes Available in Winnipeg
At Mr. Garbage, we offer a wide range of walk-in, easy-load bins ranging from 17 yards (small) to 40 yards (big). Here’s a quick breakdown:
| Size | Capacity | Dimensions (approx.) | Ideal For |
|---|---|---|---|
| 17 yd (Small) | 3–4 pickup loads | 14′ L x 8′ W x 4′ H | Garage cleanouts, small renovations |
| 20–26 yd (Medium) | 5–6 pickup loads | 14.5’–20′ L x 8′ W | Basement renos, deck removal |
| 30–40 yd (Big) | 7–10+ pickup loads | 17’–22′ L x 8′ W x 6′ H | Full house cleanouts, large demo jobs |
When to Choose a Small Bin Rental in Winnipeg
A small bin (17–20 yards) is ideal when:
- You’re doing a garage or shed cleanup
- You’re renovating a single room (like a bathroom or small kitchen)
- You need to stay within tight space constraints (narrow driveways or alleys)
- You’re working with a limited budget
- You want to avoid overfilling a bin you can’t fully use
Cost Example:
At Mr. Garbage, our 17-yard bin is $253 for 7 days, with $11.99/day after that and $99/ton dump charges. That’s one of the most cost-effective options in Winnipeg!
When to Choose a Big Bin Rental in Winnipeg
Large bins (30–40 yards) are better suited for:
- Whole-home cleanouts or estate clearances
- Large construction/demolition jobs
- Moving-day junk removal (especially if you’re downsizing)
- Projects that generate a high volume of debris (drywall, concrete, wood, etc.)
- Commercial cleanups or warehouse waste removal
Cost Example:
Our largest 40-yard bin is $349 for 7 days, with a $15/day extension rate and $99/ton dumping. That’s incredible value considering the space and efficiency you get.
Why Size Matters: Overfilling a Bin Can Cost You
Going with a small bin to “save money” can backfire if you end up overfilling it. Overweight or overflowing bins are subject to additional fees, and in many cases, you’ll need to order a second bin anyway.
To avoid this:
- Estimate your junk volume in advance
- Discuss your project with a local expert (like us!)
- Leave room for “surprise” items you may have overlooked
Winnipeg-Specific Considerations
Living and working in Winnipeg means you need a bin provider who understands the local bylaws, permit rules, and weather conditions. Here’s what makes Mr. Garbage your best bet:
- No permit fees – we cover the first 3 days for street bins
- Flexible delivery – our hook-lift trucks drop bins in tight urban spaces
- Service across all Winnipeg neighborhoods – from River Heights to Transcona
- 24/7 support and quick turnaround times – we’re local and reliable
- Transparent pricing with a copy of the dump bill
Real Reviews from Winnipeg Customers
“We use Mr. Garbage every time we do a big demo project. Thanks for your patience and dropping bins in tight spots!” – Justin Maes
“Easy to book, quick response, great service. Highly recommended!” – William Degagne
“Prompt delivery, great prices. Russell was fantastic to deal with.” – Chris Musto.
Still Not Sure Which Bin You Need?
We get it—choosing the right bin can feel overwhelming. That’s why we offer free consultations and clear guidance based on your needs. Whether it’s a quick cleanout or a major overhaul, we’ll help you pick the right size without upselling.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the difference between big bin and small bin rental in Winnipeg?
Big bins (30–40 yards) are ideal for large cleanouts or construction debris, while small bins (17–20 yards) are better suited for smaller home projects or garage cleanups.
2. How do I choose between a big bin and a small bin for junk removal in Winnipeg?
Consider your project’s scale, volume of waste, space available, and budget. When in doubt, it’s often safer to size up.
3. What size is considered a big bin rental in Winnipeg?
A big bin in Winnipeg typically ranges from 30 to 40 cubic yards, with dimensions up to 22 feet long and 6 feet high.
4. What’s the cost difference between big and small bin rentals in Winnipeg?
At Mr. Garbage, small bins start at $253 for 7 days, while big bins go up to $349, with additional daily and dump fees applied as needed.
5. Can a big bin be delivered in a tight Winnipeg location?
Yes! Mr. Garbage uses hook-lift trucks that can place bins in tight spots like narrow driveways, back alleys, or urban job sites.
6. What happens if I overfill a small bin in Winnipeg?
Overfilled bins may incur additional charges or require a second bin. Choosing the right size upfront helps avoid these extra costs.
7. Is a permit needed for big bin rental in Winnipeg?
Not with Mr. Garbage. We cover street permit costs for the first 3 days, saving you both time and money.
8. Can I rent a big bin in Winnipeg for a home renovation?
Absolutely. Big bins are perfect for full-home renovations, roofing jobs, or large-scale cleanouts.
9. How long can I keep a garbage bin rental in Winnipeg?
All Mr. Garbage bins come with a 7-day rental period, with low-cost extensions starting at just $11.99/day.
10. Do big bins cost more to dump in Winnipeg?
Dumping costs are based on weight. Both big and small bins are charged at $99/ton, regardless of size, plus applicable taxes and fees.
Book Your Bin Today with Mr. Garbage
Mr. Garbage is proud to be Winnipeg’s trusted source for affordable garbage bin rentals. From small weekend projects to large construction jobs, we have the perfect bin for you—delivered on time, at a price you’ll love.