When it comes to renting garbage bins or dumpsters in Winnipeg, two names often stand out: Bin There Dump That and Mr. Garbage. But which service truly delivers better value, convenience, and local reliability?
If you’re a homeowner tackling a renovation project, a contractor managing a job site, or simply someone doing a major clean-out, choosing the right bin rental company is crucial. This blog offers a comprehensive comparison of these two bin rental providers, enabling you to make an informed decision tailored to your specific needs.
Understanding the Local Market
Winnipeg is a growing city with a booming real estate and renovation market. As property improvements and commercial builds increase, so does the demand for efficient, affordable bin rental solutions. From residential decluttering to full-scale construction debris removal, a reliable bin service can save time, effort, and money.
Two leading providers — Bin There Dump That and Mr. Garbage — claim to offer the best bin rental experience. But let’s break down what they offer and how they differ.
What Is Bin There Dump That?
Bin There Dump That is a franchise-based bin rental service operating in various parts of Canada and the U.S., including Winnipeg. Known for their neat, driveway-safe dumpsters and residential-focused service, they aim to make bin rental simple and hassle-free.
Key Features:
- Offers multiple bin sizes (commonly 4 to 20 yards)
- Emphasizes residential service
- Driveway protection included
- Franchise-based model (local operators under a national brand)
What Is Mr. Garbage?
Mr. Garbage, on the other hand, is a locally owned and operated Winnipeg-based waste removal company. With deep roots in the community, Mr. Garbage focuses on both residential and commercial bin rentals, providing flexible pricing and personalized customer service.
Key Features:
- Bin sizes for all needs (6 to 20 yards)
- Affordable pricing with no hidden fees
- Local Winnipeg ownership = faster response times
- Excellent reputation for same-day service
- Transparent, flexible rental durations
Pricing Comparison: What You’ll Pay
One of the most important factors when choosing a bin rental company is price. Let’s explore the differences:
Bin There Dump That
- Prices vary by franchise location
- Typically includes a flat rate with a weight limit
- Additional charges for extra days or weight overages
- Some customers report higher average costs compared to local services
Mr. Garbage
- Local flat rates starting from $139*
- Clear pricing structure with no surprise fees
- Affordable daily rates beyond the standard rental period
- Tailored pricing based on your exact needs
Tip: Always ask about overage fees and maximum weight included. Mr. Garbage is often more flexible.
Customer Experience: National Brand vs. Local Business
Bin There Dump That
- Operates under a franchising model, which may result in variable customer experiences
- May require more lead time for delivery and pickup
- Website booking is convenient, but not always locally responsive
Mr. Garbage
- Winnipeg-based customer service team = real people, local knowledge
- Same-day and emergency delivery is often available
- Highly rated for responsiveness and personal service
- Preferred by contractors and homeowners for flexibility
Bin Options and Sizes
Both companies offer multiple sizes, but availability and flexibility differ.
Bin There Dump That
- 4-yard, 9-yard, 14-yard, and 20-yard bins
- Designed to fit tight spaces (great for residential driveways)
Mr. Garbage
- 6-yard, 10-yard, 15-yard, and 20-yard bins
- Ideal for both residential cleanups and heavy-duty renovation jobs
- Heavy-duty bins with easy loading features
Who Should You Choose in Winnipeg?
If you’re looking for:
- Fast, responsive local service
- Transparent, budget-friendly pricing
- Flexible options for residential or commercial waste
- Support from a business that knows Winnipeg inside and out
Then the choice is clear: Mr. Garbage is the better bin rental option for Winnipeg residents and businesses.
Environmental Responsibility
Both companies aim to dispose of waste responsibly, but Mr. Garbage goes the extra mile with local partnerships for recycling and eco-friendly practices. Their smaller carbon footprint (as a local business) also means less fuel usage during bin transport.
Real Winnipeg Reviews: What Customers Are Saying
Bin There Dump That
“Bin was okay, but a bit pricey and took an extra day to pick up.”
“Franchise model makes customer support less responsive.”
Mr. Garbage
“Delivered on time, picked up same day. Fantastic service!”
“No hidden costs — just what I was quoted. Will use again.”
Final Verdict: Bin There Dump That vs. Mr. Garbage
| Scenario | Best Option |
|---|---|
| Quick and affordable local bin | Mr. Garbage |
| National brand preference | Bin There Dump That |
| Eco-friendly and hands-on help | Mr. Garbage |
| Driveway-friendly compact bins | Both |
| Personalized customer support | Mr. Garbage |
| Transparent pricing | Mr. Garbage |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the difference between Bin There Dump That and Mr. Garbage in Winnipeg?
Bin There Dump That is a national franchise bin rental service, while Mr. Garbage is a local Winnipeg company known for affordable pricing, personalized service, and fast delivery.
Is Bin There Dump That available in Winnipeg?
Yes, Bin There Dump That operates in Winnipeg as a local franchise offering driveway-friendly bin rentals for residential use.
Why should I choose Mr. Garbage over Bin There Dump That?
Mr. Garbage offers transparent pricing, same-day delivery, and a locally managed experience with no franchise overhead, making it a smart choice for Winnipeg residents.
Which bin rental company has better reviews in Winnipeg?
Mr. Garbage consistently receives positive reviews for its reliability, affordable rates, and friendly service tailored to Winnipeg homeowners and businesses.
Are garbage bin rentals from Mr. Garbage cheaper than Bin There Dump That?
Yes, Mr. Garbage generally offers more competitive pricing with no hidden fees, making it a better value for local projects.
Do both companies offer the same bin sizes?
Both offer a range of bin sizes, but Mr. Garbage provides more flexible size options tailored to local needs and availability.
Is Mr. Garbage a locally owned business in Winnipeg?
Yes, Mr. Garbage is proudly locally owned and operated, serving Winnipeg with fast, efficient, and cost-effective waste solutions.
Do either company offer eco-friendly disposal options?
Mr. Garbage focuses on responsible disposal practices by recycling and diverting landfill waste whenever possible.
Which service is better for construction and renovation waste in Winnipeg?
Mr. Garbage is ideal for construction and renovation projects thanks to its wide bin selection and flexible rental terms.
How quickly can I get a bin delivered by Mr. Garbage in Winnipeg?
Mr. Garbage offers fast delivery, often the same day, for most Winnipeg neighborhoods.
Ready to Book a Bin in Winnipeg?
At Mr. Garbage, we don’t just drop off bins — we deliver value, service, and peace of mind. Whether you’re cleaning out your home, renovating your kitchen, or managing a job site, our waste container solutions are built to make your life easier.
Get a free quote today or call us for same-day bin rental in Winnipeg.